Why I Ditched My Traditional Garden and Never Looked Back
There was a time when I believed a "real" garden meant rows of tilled soil, annoying sunburns and mosquito bites, aching knees, and endless hours under the sun. But after years of trying (and failing) to make that work, I tried something different… and it completely changed the game.
Enter: bucket gardening. It's simple, flexible, and surprisingly productive—especially for those of us who don't have the time, space, or patience for the old-fashioned approach.
Curious what makes it so great?
Keep reading for 10 reasons bucket gardening beats the traditional setup and why it might just be your next garden obsession.
1. Perfect for Small Spaces
No yard? No problem! Bucket gardening is ideal for anyone working with limited square footage. Whether you live in an apartment, a townhouse, or don't want to commit to digging up your lawn, buckets give you the freedom to grow fresh produce just about anywhere.
Line them up along a sunny balcony, cluster them on your front porch, or even tuck them onto a wide windowsill. With the right amount of light and a little TLC (tender loving care), you'll be harvesting veggies without ever setting foot in a traditional garden.
2. Budget-Friendly Gardening
Think gardening has to be expensive? Think again. One of the biggest perks of bucket gardening is its affordability, making it easy to get started. You don't need fancy raised beds, expensive planters, or numerous tools. I grabbed some basic 5-gallon buckets from Menards, drilled some drainage holes in the bottom, and that was it—instant garden setup. I also got some ceramic planters on clearance.
Another idea is to reuse old buckets you have lying around (make sure they're food-safe and haven't held anything toxic). Compared to the cost of building or buying traditional garden beds, buckets are a budget-friendly option that still delivers significant results.
3. Portable Plants
One of the biggest advantages of bucket gardening? Total mobility. Unlike traditional gardens, your plants aren't stuck in the ground so that you can move them wherever, whenever.
- Want to chase the sun across your balcony or patio? Easy.
- Need to bring them under cover during a heavy rain or windstorm? Done.
Buckets also give you a head start on the season and a safety net at the end. If an early frost threatens your fall harvest, carry your buckets indoors, into the garage, or under a sheltered space for the night. No more watching your hard work shrivel up because the forecast turned unexpectedly cold.
Whether you're protecting, repositioning, or just redecorating your garden setup, portable plants make life (and growing) a whole lot easier.
4. Weather Control
Mother Nature doesn't always play nice, but with bucket gardening, you've got options. Unlike traditional garden beds that are stuck in one spot (rain or shine), buckets give you the upper hand when the weather gets wild.
If there's too much rain, you can move your buckets under a covered patio, awning, or into a shed or garage to prevent your plants from drowning or developing root rot. On the flip side, if a heatwave is baking your garden, you can shift your buckets into partial shade or bring them inside during the hottest part of the day to prevent wilting.
You're not at the mercy of sudden storms, scorching sun, or random cold snaps—you're in control. With a few quick moves, your plants stay safe, happy, and growing strong, no matter what the forecast throws your way.
5. Ideal for Beginners
If you're new to gardening, starting with a traditional in-ground setup can feel overwhelming fast. Between digging, amending soil, spacing plants, battling bugs, and constantly pulling weeds, it can go from fun to frustrating in no time.
Seriously, how do the weeds grow faster than the actual vegetables? And why does it feel like the weeding is never done?
That's why bucket gardening is such a perfect entry point. It simplifies the entire process, providing a manageable way to learn the basics, such as how often to water, what type of soil your plants prefer, and how much sun they need. There's no giant patch of earth to maintain, no complicated landscaping, and best of all… no endless war with weeds.
You get to focus on the fun part: growing food, watching your plants thrive, and gaining confidence season by season. For first-timers and curious dabblers alike, buckets are a low-stress, high-reward way to get started with gardening.
6. Fewer Pests and Weeds
One of the biggest headaches in a traditional garden is the constant battle with weeds and pests. In my yard, thistles and amaranth pop up like unwelcome guests, taking over if I'm not vigilant. While I'm happy to leave some milkweed growing to support the monarch butterflies—it's a beautiful reminder of nature's balance—most invasive plants can quickly sap the energy from your fruits and veggies.
Bucket gardening helps significantly reduce these issues. Because your plants are contained, it's easier to spot pests early and remove them before they spread. Additionally, weeds have a harder time invading a well-managed container than they do sprawling garden beds. You don't have to spend hours battling invasive plants that feel impossible to fully eradicate.
With buckets, you keep the weeds at bay and create a more controlled environment where your plants can thrive with less constant vigilance—and more time for enjoying the harvest.
7. Better Drainage Control
One of the silent killers of garden plants is overwatering, and it's surprisingly easy to do, especially for beginners. When soil holds too much water, roots can suffocate and begin to rot, often leading to plant decline or death. Traditional garden beds can be unpredictable when it comes to drainage, depending on soil type and weather conditions.
With bucket gardening, you're in the driver's seat. You get to drill your own drainage holes in the bottom of each bucket, making sure excess water can escape freely. This helps prevent waterlogged roots and gives you control over your plants' moisture levels.
By customizing drainage, you can dial in exactly how much water your produce plants need—no guesswork, no soggy soil disasters. It's a simple step that makes a huge difference in keeping your plants healthy, happy, and thriving season after season.
8. Eco-Friendly Option
Bucket gardening is a surprisingly sustainable method for growing your own food. Instead of buying brand-new plastic pots or investing in heavy raised beds, you can repurpose food-grade buckets you already have, or easily find secondhand. By upcycling these containers, you're keeping plastic out of the landfill and giving these buckets a second life.
This method reduces waste and minimizes the need for new materials, making your gardening practice more environmentally friendly. Additionally, because buckets are reusable from season to season, you're reducing the constant need for disposable gardening supplies.
Whether you're an eco-warrior or just looking to reduce your footprint, bucket gardening is a smart, green choice that proves growing fresh food can be both simple and sustainable.
If you prefer to buy plantlings from the store, consider checking with local produce farmers or schools to see if they would like to use them before discarding them. No pots go to waste if you give them to someone who will happily use them.
Every year, I tend to give my small nursery pots away to my former band teacher. He teaches a horticulture class at the local high school, assisted by the science teacher. He also grows a lot of produce plants as a fundraiser to support the band department.
Check out my bucket-grown lineup—proof that small-space gardening can yield big results.
9. Grow a Surprising Variety
Do you think buckets are just for herbs or tiny tomato plants? Think again. One of the most surprising aspects of bucket gardening is the numerous plants that thrive in a container setup. With the right soil, sunlight, and a little love, you can grow everything from leafy greens to root vegetables—even fruiting plants like peppers.
This season alone, my bucket gardening includes a seriously impressive lineup:
- Swiss chard (top left)
- Turnips (top middle)
- Snap peas (top right)
- Rutabaga (middle left)
- Spinach (middle center)
- Lettuce (middle right)
- Purple basil (bottom left)
- Jalapeños (bottom middle)
- Beets (bottom right)
It's not just about saving space. It's about expanding what's possible in a small footprint. Whether you're craving crisp greens, spicy peppers, earthy root veggies, or fragrant herbs, a simple 5-gallon bucket can help you grow it all. You might be surprised just how much abundance can fit into a container garden.
10. Fresh Food at Your Fingertips
There's something incredibly rewarding about stepping outside and harvesting part of your next meal—no store run, no plastic packaging, no guessing how long it's been sitting on a shelf. With bucket gardening, your food is just a few steps away, growing in plain sight and ready whenever you are.
Whether it's grabbing a handful of fresh spinach for your morning smoothie, snipping purple basil to top your pasta, or pulling up a plump turnip for a cozy soup, there's a deep satisfaction in growing what you eat. And since you're in control of what you plant, you can tailor your garden to your favorite meals, flavors, and seasonal cravings.
It doesn't get more local than this. Your porch, patio, or balcony becomes your own personal produce section—fresh, organic, and harvested at peak ripeness. Its convenience, flavor, and self-sufficiency are all rolled into one.
Why Buckets Might Be Your Best Gardening Bet Yet
As you can see, bucket gardening isn't just a clever workaround—it's a full-blown upgrade. Whether you're short on space, new to growing your own food, tired of wrestling with weeds, or simply want a more flexible and eco-friendly way to garden, buckets deliver on every front. From Swiss chard to snap peas and jalapeños to beets, the variety you can grow is impressive, and the convenience is unbeatable.
If you're craving fresh food without the hassle, consider giving bucket gardening a try. With a few simple supplies and a sunny spot, you'll be amazed at how much you can grow right at your fingertips.
Keep the Gardening Vibes Going
Megan McFadden
Megan McFadden
Megan McFadden
Previous Newsletters
Megan McFadden
Megan McFadden
Megan McFadden